Well, I just did some digging, and actually found
our old server admin's account on this website, which explains why we have a plugin called "rockthevote-mapvote-admin.sp" instead of just rockthevote.sp. I found the file:
http://forums.alliedmods.net/showthr...=101293&page=2 and it looks like it was something he wrote and of course didn't comment
I skimmed through the code (have some programming experience, and it looks like C enough that I can understand 90% of it) but it wasn't too clear to me. Will spend more time looking through it tomorrow though.
Long story short, I feel like nominate isn't having issues (since it seems to be working properly) I feel like our custom rtv is no longer compatible with nominate somehow.
And I checked the mapchooser.cfg, and sm_mapvote_endvote is set to "0" already
Again, my finger points to Wave's rtv mod, but that's mostly because I don't know what it does differently than the normal rtv plugin, however rtv does work right now, just only for admins (and you can't nominate maps into it). If he got the functionality working when no admins are online, I don't really know if it is still functional (hard to test being an admin myself, and would need a non-admin (not in the clan) person to try it). But yeah, not so worried about that part because I feel like if nominate can link back up to rtv everything will run smoothly (and I feel like nextmap isn't working for a similar reason, just don't know why).
Sorry that was so rambling/long, I hope it made sense. And thank you again for the continued help, I greatly appreciate it!
Also, thank you for the clarification between maplist.txt and mapcycle.txt, that makes a lot of sense!