I use Notepad++ almost always, but I was unsure if the encoding was doing anything when I clicked it. It felt very finicky when I would choose an encoding, then reopen the file and it wasn't really showing the encoding I chose just a second earlier.
Went ahead and loaded up v1.10 on my server and got the same error. So it seems it's still a bug in the current build. Not sure where to report the bug though.
This is basically solved with fysiks input. How can I mark it solved?